I had a subaru that hit a deer. It can be fixed pretty well. I found someone to do the painting pretty cheap. It looked cheap, but it was good enough for a 95. I actually bought new pieces and had them painted for less than 500. I unbent metal using a come-along and an old seatbelt. It worked great and the car turned out pretty good. Ill have to post some before/after shots.
I tell you what, check car-part.com and you local salvage yard. Many will give you crap about looking for a color, but dont worry about it. Its not their car.