2003-2005 - I had loved the look of this series for some time, which is precisely why I finally broke down and bought one. I prefer the rear tailights of the '03 and '04, however, over the all-red '05.
2006-2007 - The revised rear end absolutely killed this car for me. In fact, when I bought my '03 I mentioned to the dealer that this is why I did not purchase one a bit newer and he stated that this was a very common complaint about the car.
2008 - I absolutely love the redsign! In fact, it is very likely to be my next car (in a few years, as I prefer to buy them 3-4 years old). I know it is quite a departure from the status quo, but a good one in my opinion.